How Regime Supporters Used a New York Times Reporter (Again) To Denoun

محروم.كوم · #1 05-09-2012, 11:00 PM

Bahrain Special: How Regime Supporters Used a New York Times Reporter (Again) To Denounce the Opposition

Almost three weeks ago, in a feature and a follow-up, we revealed how three supporters of the Bahraini regime, amidst tension and clashes around the Bahrain Grand Prix, introduced themselves as the "silent majority" to three Formula 1 journalists. The men, with a great deal of success, promoted the monarchy, especially Crown Prince Salman, as the symbol of moderation and reform while characterising protesters as a violent, misguided, Iran-led minority.
Two days before that, we considered how Souad Mekhennet of The New York Times --- allowed, unlike other journalists such as her colleague like Nicholas Kristof, into the country --- proclaimed, "Bahrain Holds Grand Prix, Keeping Protesters at Bay". Indeed, she went farther, portraying the opposition as fragmented, with one faction denouncing another for the use of violence. She portrayed activist Zainab Alkhawaja --- now in prison like her father and fellow activist, hunger striker Abdulhadi Alkhawaja --- as a supporter of that violence: "Ms. Khawaja rejected the argument that demonstrations should always be peaceful. When asked if she would call on protesters to refrain from using bombs, she said: “It really amazes me when people ask if I will condemn it. I will not.”
But could this propaganda success be extended by merging the two strands? Could Mekhennet, representing America's best-known newspaper, be introduced to people who would reinforce her denunciation of the opposition?
From Tuesday's New York Times, "Losing Faith With Protesters in Bahrain", written by Souad Mekhennet:
No member of this trio ever planned on staying on this island. They had come either to visit friends or to work a one-year contract in the Gulf state.
But they never left — and now they offer an interesting view of the stirrings in Bahrain, which unlike any of the other Arab states affected by uprisings in the past year, has a majority population of expatriates.
The three unmarried, childless Western women — Carol Melrose, a 56-year-old Briton; Abby Navarre, a 53-year-old Briton; and Sarah, a 29-year-old American who asked not to be further identified — said life before the uprisings had been relaxed....
Now, they are caught between the government and demonstrators. At the outset, they said, they were very sympathetic toward the protesters because they had witnessed discrimination against Shiites applying for jobs or housing....
The women have all changed their opinion in recent months. “We all know that the protesters have their issues, and no expatriate is denying it,” said Ms. Navarre. “But the king has already started with reforms and at this stage, the protesters should get back to their life and give the government a chance to implement the reforms.”
As with other supposedly impromptu interviews such as last month's encounter with the Formula 1 journalists, the speakers praise the monarchy, "All three women...welcomed the king’s initiative to bring in an independent commission. 'You don’t have many leaders who would accept doing this,' Sarah said."

They, with Mekhennet as the scribe, portray protesters as the cause of conflict, with security forces only acting in response:
All three women live close to Budaiya Road, where the largest opposition group, Al Wefaq, holds its mostly authorized and peaceful rallies. When these rallies end, younger people, who claim to be part of the February 14th movement, sometimes turn violent. Stones, Molotov cocktails and, in some cases, gasoline bombs fly in the direction of the police, who answer with abundant tear gas and, protesters say, birdshot....
“Imagine in the U.S. protesters would throw Molotov cocktails and burn tires in D.C. or New York. What do you think would the police do?” [Sarah] said.
And Carol, Abby, and Sarah effectively blame the opposition --- rather than, as other analysts have evaluated, the regime --- for fostering sectarian conflict:
All three said one reason they had stayed in Bahrain was its openness — a Gulf state with Roman Catholic and Protestant churches, synagogues, Hindu and Baha’i temples.
“We never used to hear the question if someone was Shiite or Sunni, but now you can even hear children talking about it,” Ms. Melrose said....
They said the gap between Shiites and others has grown. Ms. Melrose worries that the next generation of Bahrainis will grow up with the idea that Shiites and Sunnis are different. “It is too bad to see that this multicultural society gets ruined,” she said.
As we noted in previous articles, there is nothing untoward about an individual in Bahrain offering his/her perspective and opinion. It is a far different matter, however, to present that individual view through an interview like this as that of the no-longer-silent majority, ignoring or stigmatising the opinions of others.

In this case, however, Mekhennet adds a significant distortion. Her dramatic device is that the three women have had a road-to-Manama conversion, once supporting the opposition but now seeing the light:
At the outset, they said, they were very sympathetic toward the protesters because they had witnessed discrimination against Shiites applying for jobs or housing.
“I felt it is good that the protesters were demanding more rights,” said Ms. Navarre, who works in real estate and, like Ms. Melrose, has lived in Bahrain for more than 20 years....
“Last year, I had sympathies for some of the protesters’ demands, but now I am asking myself, ‘What is this about now?”’ said Sarah, who has worked for six years at a hotel.
Again, a perspective that should be heard and noted. Except, for at least one of the women, Mekhennet could easily have discovered that it is a deception.
Abigail Navarre --- supposedly the advocate last year of protesters' "demanding more rights" --- wrote on Twitter on 5 March 2011 about the centre of the demonstrations:
http://www.enduringamerica.com/home/...ork-times.html __DEFINE_LIKE_SHARE__

المواضيع المتشابهه
الموضوع	كاتب الموضوع	المنتدى	مشاركات	آخر مشاركة
Supporters of Syrian regime rally in Damascus - Associated Press	محروم.كوم	منتدى أخبار المواقع والمنتديات العربية والأجنبية	0	03-15-2012 02:30 PM
Supporters of Syrian regime rally in Damascus - Associated Press	محروم.كوم	منتدى أخبار المواقع والمنتديات العربية والأجنبية	0	03-15-2012 02:10 PM
Posthumous Polk Award for Times Correspondent - New York Times	محروم.كوم	منتدى أخبار المواقع والمنتديات العربية والأجنبية	0	02-20-2012 08:52 AM
Posthumous Polk Award for Times Correspondent - New York Times	محروم.كوم	منتدى أخبار المواقع والمنتديات العربية والأجنبية	0	02-20-2012 08:11 AM
Posthumous Polk Award for Times Correspondent - New York Times	محروم.كوم	منتدى أخبار المواقع والمنتديات العربية والأجنبية	0	02-20-2012 07:30 AM